Umutina, Os [The Umutina] (1945) – dir. Harald Schultz*

A father sings to his recently deceased son at a place in the forest that they had visited together – Os Umutina (1945) – dir. Harald Schultz.

22 mins., b&w, sound, titles in Portuguese

Production : Serviço de Proteção aos Índios (SPI), Ministério da Agricultura.

Source : This film is held at the Museu do Índio, Rio de Janeiro, though the copy available for public viewing lacks sound. It can also be viewed on-line here, though in addition to the lack of sound, there has clearly been a technical problem with the upload of the second half of the film.

The film is also available as part of the Encyclopaedia Cinematographica collection held by TIB, the German National Library as detailed here. A transcript of the voice-over commentary in both Portuguese and German is available here.

The TIB also holds many other shorter films by the director,  Harald Schultz. These include Totenkulttänze [Dances of the Cult of the Dead] released in 1962 and shot at the same time as Os Umutina. This concerns three dances performed at an annual ritual commemoration of the dead. It is silent, has a running time of 4 ½ mins and, significantly, it is in colour.

A study guide in German relating to this shorter film is available here. This provides background context that is also useful for understanding the main film.

Here Schultz explains that he was working with a mixture of 16mm and 35mm stock using a Bolex camera for the former and a Bell & Howell for the latter. The stock was mostly black and white since due to the fact that the Second World War was going on at the time, it was not possible to get sufficient colour stock to shoot the whole film. Schultz also made location sound recordings of music.

Schultz seems to have decided to reserve the colour stock for shooting the most important ritual performances. While this is understandable, this decision had the unfortunate consequence that these events were not included in the main film, presumably precisely because they were in colour. Instead, they were reserved for a separate film that was not released until more than fifteen years later and which did not carry any sound.

Background: Traditionally, the Umutina lived on various small right-bank tributaries of the upper Paraguay River, in western Mato Grosso,  between the Sepotuba and Bugres rivers. Their language is considered to be distantly related to Bororo, and there are also certain cultural features that are common to both groups, though there are also some major differences.

‘Umutina’ is a relatively recent term, dating only from the 1930s and first used by other indigenous groups to refer to them. In earlier texts, they are often referred to as the Barbados (literally, the ‘bearded ones’) on account of the light beards that men traditionally wore, unusually for an Amazonian indigenous people.

The Umutina came into violent contact with non-indigenous people in the late nineteenth century and were not pacified by the SPI until 1911. At that time, their population is estimated to have been around 300 individuals, but an outbreak of measles in 1919 reduced them to 200. Due to the effects of further epidemics, by the time that Harald Schultz first came to study them in 1943, they had been reduced to 73 individuals, of whom 50 were living on the SPI post.

Harald Schultz among the Umutina (photograph in Schultz 1954, p.73).

The remaining Umutina were then living in a single village of three or four houses on a tributary of the upper Paraguay River. This is the group that is the subject of this film. Schultz made three visits to this village, totalling eight months, spread over three years, 1943, 1944 and 1945. The material for the film was shot in the course of the latter two visits. It is also this group that is the principal subject of the fieldwork memoir that Schultz published in 1954 and which alluded in its title to the fact that at that time, there were only 23 of them.

In 1945, while Schultz was visiting them, this group suffered an outbreak of whooping cough, and despite his attempts to aid them medically, they were reduced to only 15 people. Shortly afterwards, they too moved into the SPI post.

The Umutina continue to live on the site of the former SPI post and have been assigned a territory in the vicinity. By 2014, their population had increased to 515 but they are now extensively intermarried with the Paresí and Nambikwara who also live at the former SPI post and they no longer speak their own language. (More detailed information about the life of the Umutina today is available here).

Os Umutina and Totenkulttänze therefore represent the final period of the Umutina’s existence as an autonomous people living freely in the forest.

In the study guide for the supplementary colour film, Totenkulttänze, Schultz remarks that his filming was cut short when he suffered ‘a serious accident’. In fact, as described in his fieldwork memoir, this consisted of the severe wounding that he suffered when his aggrieved interpreter (an Umutina man who had grown up outside the group) attacked him with a knife, almost killing him.

The technical quality of the Schultz’s cinematography in Os Umutina is remarkably good. In contrast to most of his many later films, which primarily consist of very short works of descriptive documentation, this film is clearly intended to  be a documentary in the sense that the material has been skilfully re-ordered and cut in accordance with the editorial codes of the period.

In his preface to Schultz’s fieldwork memoir, which was published in 1954, Herbert Baldus, who was Schultz’s principal academic patron and a foundational figure in modern Brazilian anthropology, described this work as “one of the best films that has yet been made of a South American tribe”. It was a view that he would reiterate in the obituary that he wrote about Schultz after the latter’s sadly premature death in 1966.

Film Content :

The film is organised into two parts. In the first, after a preliminary map showing the location of the traditional territory of the Umutina, the film opens with a series of portraits of individuals of various different ages, illustrating their remarkable forms of body decoration and hair styling..

This is a followed by a series of sequences on crafts, broadly defined, including house-building, the making of bowstrings and arrows, digging sticks and the curing of animal skins.

In the midst of these, there is a particularly interesting sequence of an old man feeding some macaws. The voice-over explains that the Umutina consider that after death, their relatives’ souls may take up residence in certain animals and particularly birds, which they then adopt as pets and look after with great care. This does not, however, prevent them from using their feathers to make their body ornaments.

After death, one of the three human souls are thought to take up residence in animals, particularly birds. The Umutina therefore look after their pets, such as these macaws, with particular attention.

The film then moves on to themes of subsistence, with the voice-over commenting that for the Umutina, daily life is normally a constant struggle for food. A man is shown shooting a large fish with bow and arrow, another is shown cutting down a tall tree with an axe acquired through trade with non-indigenous people. His purpose is to get at the beehive in its upper branches: honey, we are told, is much appreciated by the Umutina.

The final section of the first part begins with a man setting light to the roof of a house. It is explained that this is done when a family moves to a new location to prevent bad spirits congregating at the old site. However, when a family member is buried within the house, they leave the house to decay naturally.

A father sings mourning songs for his baby boy who has recently died. Beyond, the bereaved mother is comforted by her sister. In the middle, beneath a cloth, lies the grave of the recently buried child (see also the image at the top of this entry).

This introduces the theme of mortality which is then continued with a sequence in which the father and other male relatives are shown singing mourning songs following the recent death of young male child.

The second part of the film begins with a sequence showing a fishing expedition that involves the damming and poisoning of a river. This is followed by a brief sequence about horticulture and the cultivation of maize, the principal crop.

But the main business of this part of the film are the ceremonies that take place at the time of the maize harvest,  early in the rainy season, when the struggle for subsistence is less intense than usual.

A woman caresses the foot of one of the dancers whom she believes has embodied the spirit of her dead husband. [Not shown in the film, see the Totenkulttänze study guide, p.6]
The main purpose of these ceremonies is to commemorate the dead whose spirits are attracted to the event and take up residence in the bodies of the dancers. The ceremonies take place within a specially prepared clearing in the forest, at one end of which a house for the spirits is built. This is enclosed on all sides in the traditional Umutina manner, and the entry of women is strictly forbidden. Within it, the dancers dress in the palm-leaf cloaks that they will wear for the ceremony.

The film shows the structure being built and then various sequences of dancing. As night falls, a guttural singing in imitation of bird calls and the sound of flutes announces the arrival of the spirits of the dead. A second form of dance begins and the dancers go into a sort of ecstasy as the spirits enter their bodies.

In a final intervention, the voice-over reflects on whether the spirits know that the end is nigh for a “once great indigenous tribe”.

Texts: Schultz 1952, Schultz 1954, Baldus 1966.

Haut Amazone: pays des réducteurs de têtes [Upper Amazon: Country of the Head-Shrinkers] (1939) – dir. Fred Matter *

‘Omitsin’, the Aénts Chicham (Jívaro) shaman  – Haute Amazone (1939) – dir. Fred Matter

39 mins., b&w, sound, 39 mins. Voice-over narration in French.

Production : produced in France, but production company not named.

Source : CNC at the Bnf ( 139824)

Based on 1936-37 expedition to the Ecuadorian Amazon led by ethnologist Bertrand Flornoy, also including geographer Jean de Guébriant, and Fred Matter, the cinematographer, who also directed and edited the material.

This post is a stub and will be developed later.

SaveSave

SaveSave

Turnbull, Colin (1924-1994)*

Joseph Towles with Colin Turnbull

As an anthropologist, Colin Turnbull’s reputation rests primarily on two much-cited books on the Mbuti hunter-gatherer ‘pygmies’ who live in the Ituri forest, in what was still the Eastern Province of the Belgian Congo when Turnbull began his studies in the 1950s. Later, after independence from Belgium in 1960, it became part of Zaire, and more recently, in 1997, three years after Turnbull had died, the Democratic Republic of Congo (Turnbull 1962, 1965).

Turnbull reputation became more controversial following a later book, on the Ik people, of northeastern Uganda, with whom he carried out fieldwork in the period 1965-67. Turnbull claimed that the Ik were hunter-gatherers who had been obliged to become sedentary, and that as a result, all human norms of civility and social organisation had collapsed among this people (Turnbull 1972). This book was severely contested at the time that it was published, and subsequently it has been claimed that it was based on an inadequate understanding of both the language and the most basic social facts of Ik society (Heine 1985, Grinker 2000).

Turnbull was unusual among British anthropologists of his generation in having an interest in film-making, and made films during the course of his fieldwork both with the Mbuti and with the Ik. While conducting fieldwork in 1954, Turnbull collaborated with his cousin, Francis S. Chapman, a Canadian Broadcasting Corporation cameraman, to shoot footage with the Mbuti.

Almost two decades later, in 1971-72, he collaborated with fellow anthropologist, Joseph A. Towles (1937-1988) to shoot further material among the Mbuti. In between these shoots, he also worked with Towles on a film about the Ik during their joint 1965-67 fieldwork. It is not clear who, if anyone, provided technical assistance in these two later shoots.

Turnbull and Towles were not only colleagues in the field, but also partners in life,  exchanging marriage vows in 1960, long before homosexual relationships became legal in either the US or the UK. When Towles died in 1988 of complications arising from AIDS, Turnbull donated not only their joint work, but also all his own work to the Avery Research Center for African History and Culture, College of Charleston, South Carolina, where both bodies of work now make up the Joseph A. Towles Papers.

Mbuti Film Study: nkumbi initiation ceremony, footage (1971-72) – dir. Joseph A. Towles *

85 mins., col., silent.

Source : NAFC, catalogue no. AF-91.13.5.

[Notes based on NAFC catalogue entry]

Footage shot in and around the Ndaka (Bantu) village of Epulu,
 in the Ituri Forest in the northeast region of the Democratic Republic of Congo (formerly Zaire and the Belgian Congo). This material appears to have been shot primarily under the direction of Joseph Allen Towles, but Colin Turnbull may also have been involved, and in the copy held by the NAFC, Turnbull provides a commentary on the material.

It is generally well shot but it is not clear by whom: certainly it was not by Towles as he appears in shot. Towles and Turnbull were partners in life as well as anthropological work and when Towles died in 1988 of complications arising from AIDS, Turnbull donated not only their joint work, but also all his own work to the Avery Research Center, where it forms the “Joseph A. Towles Collection

This footage shows how both subsistence and ritual practices
 bring the villagers and the local Mbuti ‘pygmies’ into contact. Sequences
 cover a range of topics, including house types, the harvesting of rice, the local market, and digging and kneading clay for use in 
house construction. They also cover the first nkumbi male initiation ceremony to take place in the Ituri forest since the Simba Revolt of 1964. They show the nkumbi camp, the training of initiates, masked dancers and an initiate’s head being shaved. Also included is a flag-raising ceremony at a nearby government post in commemoration of independence from Belgium in 1960.

Boy having his head shaved during nkumbi initiation ceremony, near Epulu, a Bantu village in the Ituri forest, northeast Democratic Republic of Congo (1970-71)

In his commentary, Turnbull analyses the various stages of the nkumbi ceremony but surmises that some of the material must be lost because only the latter part of the ceremony is shown. He also comments that the painting of the bodies of the initiates with a blue colour was an innovation that had been adopted around the time of the Simba Revolt. It was associated at that time with blue plastic, but also with violence and death.

See also Turnbull’s earlier edited film on the nkumbi ceremony, made in collaboration with the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation cameraman, his cousin Francis S. Chapman in 1954.

Texts : Turnbull (1962), Turnbull (1965), Grinker (2000)

 

Mbuti Film Study: subsistence activities and the elima female initiation ceremony (1954) footage – Francis S. Chapman and Colin Turnbull *

108 mins., col., sound

Source : NAFC, catalogue number AF-91.13.3

[Notes based on NAFC catalogue]

Footage shot among the Mbuti ‘pygmies’ of the Ituri Forest, still then part of the Belgian Congo
 (later to become Zaïre, and more recently the Democratic Republic of Congo). It focuses strongly on the relations between Ndaka (Bantu) villagers and the nomadic, forest-dwelling Mbuti. Subsistence activities shown 
include: an Mbuti forest camp, the construction of domed leaf houses, 
barkcloth manufacture, hunting forest deer with nets, the collection 
of honey. There is also a sequence of boys playing on a tree swing.

Ritual sequences show: a  camp on the banks of the Epulu River for
 the month-long seclusion of pubescent Mbuti girls prior to their initiation during the elima ceremony, the elima ceremony itself, and an Ndaka village wedding ceremony.
 The bride is shown being anointed with palm oil (a sign of wealth) and carried on a palanquin into 
the village, where she is regaled by dancers.

This footage was shot by a Canadian Broadcast Corporation cameraman, Francis S. Chapman, based on the field research of anthropologist Colin Turnbull. The HSFA also hold a shorter set of black and white rushes (AF 91.13.6, 35 mins.) accompanied by a recording of Turnbull commenting on them. These rushes show life in a forest camp, and nkumbi male initiation ceremonies at Ngawana village of Musafu and the Bira village of Eboyo.

Chapman and Turnbull also produced an edited colour film about the nkumbi initiation ceremony (Mbuti Film Study, AF-91.13.4)

They also collaborated on making audio recordings of Mbuti music, released in 1992 in the Smithsonian Folkways series. For details, see here

Texts : Turnbull (1962), Turnbull (1965), Grinker (2000)

© 2018 Paul Henley