Hopi Snake Dance footage, Orayvi (1898) and Wàlpi (1899) – E. Burton Holmes and Oscar B. Depue

The Antelope Society await the arrival of the Snake Society on the “snake plaza” of Orayvi, 22 August, 1898. In the middle distance, Burton Holmes, on the left, and Oscar Depue stand beside an early moving image camera. Photograph by Adam Clark Vroman (see Mahood 1961: 97).

Shot on 60mm film. Footage lost, duration unknown.

Background: Most of this footage was shot on 22 August 1898 at the Hopi village of Orayvi and is possibly the first film of a North American Native people.

Certainly, it predates the footage shot at the Hopi village of Wàlpi by an Edison crew in 1901 which is sometimes identified as the first film on the Hopi Snake Dance. It also considerably predates the Snake Dance material shot by the celebrated photographer, Edward S. Curtis, also at Orayvi, in 1904 and 1906.

This footage is sometimes erroneously attributed to Thomas Edison, but in fact was shot by Oscar Depue, a cameraman working for the celebrated travel lecturer, E. Burton Holmes. In the photograph above, Depue is seen standing behind the camera, while Holmes is standing by his side, to the left. In 1899, they returned to the region and shot further footage of the Snake Dance ceremony in the Hopi village of Wàlpi.

The camera is particularly interesting as it is a modified version of the rare Chronophotographe, devised by the French inventor Georges Demenÿ for the media entrepreneur Léon Gaumont. A distinctive feature of this camera was that it operated with 60mm film.

Acting on Holmes’ behalf, Depue had purchased an example the previous year in Paris and had modified it so that it could carry a longer roll of film. In this modified form, the camera became known in the US as the “Depue Chronomatograph”.

Apart from a single damaged frame reproduced in a study of the work of the photographer who took the image at the head of this entry, Adam Clark Vroman, the Holmes-Depue footage is currently lost.

However, its content can be reconstructed from various sources: the extensive photographic record made of this  performance of the Hopi Snake Dance, the written testimonies of eyewitnesses, including Holmes himself, and the many subsequent reports on the footage that appeared in the press as the Snake Dance films became an important part of Holmes’ lecture repertoire. 

Content : We know from the eyewitness account of Paul Ehrenreich, a German anthropologist, that Depue began early in the morning of 22 August when he filmed a preparatory ceremony, some hours prior to the main event, in which a group of women and girls attempted to wrestle away sheaves of cornstalks from a group of men and boys who were arriving in the village at the end of an early-morning footrace. 

As for the main event, the single surviving frame suggests that after filming from the initial position shown in the photograph above, Depue moved his camera a few metres to the left, probably in order to get a better view of the snake-dancing that constitutes the second phase of the ceremony.

There is no evidence that on this occasion Depue was able to film the last phase of the ceremony in which the snakes are taken back to the desert so that they can carry a plea to the spirits who control the rain. Holmes’ account suggests that by this point , light conditions had deteriorated badly, so Depue may have found it impossible to film. It may be for this reason that Holmes and Depue returned the following year to Wàlpi, i.e., to film the final phase that they had been unable to capture at Orayvi.

There is some evidence for this is the newspaper reports of Holmes’ lectures since it is only  in the autumn of 1899, after Holmes and Depue had been to Wàlpi, that they mention the returning of the snakes to the desert.

What is not in doubt is that the Snake Dance films provoked a great deal of interest. They remained a staple of Holmes’ lectures for the following six years, culminating in 1904 when he took them to London. Thereafter, however, he seems to have set this material aside and turned his attention to European and Asian subjects.

Texts: Ehrenreich 1899: 155, Holmes 1901, Depue 1947, Mahood 1961: 97, Webb and Weinstein 1973: 20, Henley and Whiteley ms.

Holmes, E. Burton (1870-1958)*

Burton Holmes, on the right, with his cameraman, Oscar Depue (1869-1960) in 1911. Between them is an Urban Bioscope 35mm camera. Photographer unknown.

Although today a largely forgotten figure, in his lifetime, E. Burton Holmes was a major media celebrity in the US, sufficiently so to be awarded a star in the pavement of Hollywood Boulevard. Although probably not the originator of the term, it was Holmes who was the first leading exponent of the ‘travelogue’ film.

Every autumn and winter, from the 1890s until the 1950s, Holmes toured around the US giving travel lectures to audiences of hundreds, sometimes thousands of people. These were based on his own expeditions all across the world which he carried out in the summer months.

An integral part of the lectures were the photographs that he himself had taken on these expeditions, but from as early as 1897, he often employed moving image cameramen to come with him. The first of these was Oscar Depue, who appears in the photograph above.

Initially, the footage was screened as a novelty supplement at the end of the lectures, but as the technology developed, it became increasingly integral to Holmes’ performance. Eventually, from 1915, Holmes began directing free-standing films in which he himself would appear in exotic locations around the globe and the travelogue film genre was launched. 

Burton Holmes as an ethnographic film-maker

Holmes produced a large number of travelogue films, many of which contain passages of undoubted ethnographic interest. Although he travelled all over the world, he had a particular interest in Asia, especially Japan, which he visited many times. A short history of his film-making activities is available here

With Depue acting as the cameraman, Holmes also made what are probably the earliest ethnographic films about Native peoples of the US. These were shot during an expedition to Arizona in August 1898 and include footage of the Hopi Snake Dance as performed at Orayvi that year as well as three short films of a Navajo “tournament” which they shot at Tolani Lake on their return journey from Orayvi. The following year, Holmes and Depue returned to film the Snake Dance as performed at Wàlpi, again stopping at Tolani Lake to screen the material that they had shot of the Navajo tournament to the participants – in effect, a very early example of a “feedback screening”.

Unfortunately, this footage is currently lost and for a long time, it was misattributed to the Thomas Edison organisation. Now that it has been correctly identified as the work of Holmes and Depue, there is a greater possibility that it might emerge from the archives.

Texts : Holmes 1901, Depue 1947, Holmes 1953, Caldwell 1977, Henley and Whiteley ms.

© 2018 Paul Henley